Harper Scores on CPAC-SES Leadership Report Card

131 comments Latest by DSoulis

As you might remember, in the last federal election, the nightly CPAC-SES tracking included leadership measures (trust, competence and vision). One year later, SES and CPAC have completed a follow up leadership evaluation.

The CPAC-SES Leader Report Card indicates that after one year in power, Prime Minister Stephen Harper has noticeably improved all measures related to leadership. Compared to the eve of the federal election, he has significantly improved his leadership image score on trust (+14 points), competence (+17) and his vision for Canada (+14).

Most Trustworthy Leader

  • Harper – 35% (+14)
  • Dion – 20% (Martin - 18%)
  • Duceppe – 8% (-3)
  • Layton – 18% (-7)
  • May – 8% (Harris - 3%)

Most Competent Leader

  • Harper – 41% (+17)
  • Dion – 22% (Martin - 28%)
  • Duceppe – 8% (No change)
  • Layton – 13% (-4)
  • May – 4% (Harris - 2%)

Best Vision for Canada

  • Harper – 39% (+14)
  • Dion – 21% (Martin - 25%)
  • Duceppe – 5% (-1)
  • Layton – 16% (-2)
  • May – 7% (Harris - 3%)

Cheers, NJN

Remember to rate the views of others - to allow us to recognize the opinion leaders in our national conversation.

Individuals with the top ratings make it to Nik’s Leaderboard.

Reply to Topic

Most Read Comments

Highest Rated Comments

This isn't really a surprise. Mr Harper has come out of the gate and fit into th... more

Joe Blow (Ontario) 12 Feb 14:42

It's no surprise to me either, given the fact that Harper has had a year as PM a... more

Interested_1 (Ontario) 12 Feb 15:42

I agree, Harper, the man, has grown in the job as he ought to but, remember, he ... more

Tom Good (British Columbia) 14 Feb 01:45

Nonsense your upset only because the West is gaining more power, we should be in... more

kwlawson (British Columbia) 13 Feb 22:07

Mike the Liberals deserve it, 13 years of scams, mismangement and corruption, no... more

kwlawson (British Columbia) 17 Feb 01:07

Hi Mike: I agree the results of the SES poll do not look good for Mr. Dion and ... more

hollinm (Saskatchewan) 17 Feb 13:42

Comments

Joe Blow

This isn't really a surprise. Mr Harper has come out of the gate and fit into the roll well; especially when you compare him to the shotgun style (everything is a priority) of Mr Martin. Mr Harper has demonstrated decisiveness and clarity of purpose (albeit sometimes lacking in media communication strategies), maintaining that all important Prime Ministerial look.

Reply to Comment

12 Feb 14:42

21 replies so far. Join this conversation.

PMK

While I agree with your thoughts on Mr. Harper's style, I must confess to being surprised by Mr. Harper's strong ratings. Most people I know have an unfavourable impression of him. These results make me think of Nixon's silent majority!

Reply to Comment

12 Feb 17:07

kwlawson

I cannot believe Im agreeing with Blow Joe in Ontario but he is right about Harper and the numbers for Dion will go down.

Reply to Comment

12 Feb 18:07

mar

But are Harper's ratings that strong?

Slightly more respondents preferred him to the other leaders BUT the percentage rating him first is quite similar to the percentage of voters favouring the Conservatives.

Doesn't that suggest after the Reform-Alliance-Conservative years conservative voters are more or less unswerving of their support for who ever is Conservative leader, while the rest of the population splits across a number of party leaders.

It reminds me of U.S Republican support where somewhere between 33% and 38% of voters will support (and say they approve of) ANY Republican presidential candidate or President.

You wonder how long either the leadership or support numbers will last when an election is called and voters face the reality of prolonging the current minority government situation by splitting votes between Liberal-NDP-Green (the BQ being a somewhat separate issue).

Reply to Comment

11 Mar 13:40

John

We hear of Harpers priorities. We still don't know his political purpose. That is what is holding back Canadians. Most agree, keep an eye on the Conservatives. The Conservatives are losing support in their more traditional areas.

Reply to Comment

12 Feb 21:04

kwlawson

oh by the way the Oil Patch does not get subsidized like the automotive and other manufacteurs in Ontario and Quebec, and the other issue, after receiving taxpayers money like street beggars why are these trains to China of Bombardier (Parasite of the Public Purse) not being manufactured in Canada, I want a investigation, but as usual will not do anything because it is in Quebec, this Dion is not a leader I tell you.

Reply to Comment

12 Feb 21:55

John

There is a big differnce between creating intellectual property through design, than having a piece of geograpghy that just lucks out by having oil under it.

As per your comment about leadership, Harper would have taken us straight to Iraq. Thats not leadership. Sometimes leadership is shown in the restarint.

Reply to Comment

12 Feb 22:21

blossom

John,
Your's are the only two intelligent answers worth reading so far.
blos

Reply to Comment

12 Feb 22:55

kwlawson

The only problem we do not get any from you Blossom, the problem is you cannot face the facts that right in front of you.

Reply to Comment

12 Feb 23:01

John

Hi Blossom,

I think things are going will go well for the country if we can change it back to some kind of a country where there is less anger and more discussion.

You live in a wonderful province with so much promise.

I just can't understand why the conservatives continue to be angry over everything.

They offer no ideas, no inspiration and no hope.

Reply to Comment

12 Feb 23:27

kwlawson

Well most westerners like me are fed up with this business of appeasing Quebec and getting all the money, at the expense of other Provinces, if they could get off their asses like Alberta did, being pushed with National Energy program of Mr Finger who I never like Trudeau and this Marc Lalonde that is still in Quebec she should have been punished for this absolutely stupid program, a stupid man with a stupid mind and program.

Reply to Comment

13 Feb 00:41

blossom

Name calling is not going to get your point across, kwlawson,
You are not the one who is appeasing Qc., and just today PM Harper made
a courageous move in order to help QC with our elections...At least, S.Harper
is trying to keep this Country united...The sums for Qc are only a portion
of what you, and all provinces are also going to get, which is calculated per capita/per
province!!! So what are you complaining about? Even the separatists could
see this as a move in order to keep this Country whole/united, and hopefully
get rid of our big problem - the 'bloc'. It was a smart move on his part, and a
first, since a budget has never been divulged before the due date, but obviously
S. Harper is using this strategy to help this province get rid of the 'bloc'.
You are so biased, that you can't even get your facts straight, even about past
history. There is nothing ever elevating about any of your statements, because
everything turns around you, you, you, and your complaints.
Incidentally, my drive is further than your vision!

Reply to Comment

13 Feb 03:55

kwlawson

All you have to do in Quebec Blossom is stop being parasites on the Public Purse, Public Service and earn you way like Alberta has done!

Reply to Comment

13 Feb 13:53

blossom

Hello John,

I can't tell you how much I appreciate your kind words. I always enjoy my visits
in Ontario; the people and family; etc...
Yes, I live in a vevy beautiful province, however, with the 'bloc'/separatist movement,
I often feel like a fish out of water.
I can not understand, like you, that with the riches of this Country, we can not
all co-operate in finding solutions that would benefit all, and not want to share the wealth.
This goes beyond politics...It is up to all of us to reach out, and make sure that
governments are in line with our ideas, inspirations, and our hopes. We should
all try to be visionaries, and see the wealth that we could all wreap, and I don't
just mean the almigthy dollar!
Thanks for the up-lifting thoughts.
Sincerely,
blos

Reply to Comment

13 Feb 03:17

kwlawson

We should be in Iraq helping the USA, something the Liberals did not do, I do not want a Liberal government in Canada for about 50 years and the same for a Prime Minister from Quebecf, they keep stealing money from the taxpayer, like the Senate of dysfunctional Chretien appointments do now.

Reply to Comment

12 Feb 23:05

John

If we don't get our beloved Liberals back sson, none of may be here in 50 years.

Reply to Comment

12 Feb 23:20

kwlawson

We do not need them all they do is steal from other Provinces and gives it Ontario and Quebec, they are the Party of Crooks Not Canadians.You trust them Not me, You must be one of them John

Reply to Comment

12 Feb 23:24

John

I was a conservative for 33 years. I had to leave it because I didn't like the way some of their supporters spoke to and about people in the house of commons. To me they became very crude. The language I considered to be abusive and I certainly didn't want to be part of an angy bunch of name calling idealogues.

Reply to Comment

12 Feb 23:35

kwlawson

Well that is your personal preference but it does make the other individuals wrong, the Liberals are simply to lax for me.

Reply to Comment

13 Feb 00:36

blossom

I can't believe that I am actually reading this stuff - Iraq was a lie; the US is
contemplating 'impeaching" bush for his lies about WMD for invading Iraq, when
he should have gone after bin laeden...you are a true worrior...The US doesn't
even know how to get out of Iraq - now 'bush' and his crony's are looking at ways
to invade Iran, when they can't even get their act together in Iraq...The US is
borrowing from their trading partners, and are in the trillions in debt...They don't
have money to educate their youth. 47k are without insurance, and after katrina,
it still looks like a third world country! We don't know where we are going with
Afghanistan, short on land troops, they need more suits, the same soldiers have
been back as much as three times - they are exhausted. Now the wives of those
fallen soldiers are not adequately getting their pensions, and their mortgages paid!!!
Those who have made it out of there, will be incapacitated for the rest of their lives -
and you want to see more Canadian troops in Iraq?
I have a suggestion for you kwlawson; why don't you enroll to Iraq, and take charge
of things out there. This way, you will never have to complain about the outcome!
I really think that this is your calling!!!

Very sincerely,
blosl

Reply to Comment

13 Feb 03:29

kwlawson

Bloss you really are going off the deep end again, you should consider seeing a doctor soon. Im not complaining about being in Iraq, I simiply said we must help the USA. Blossom are you beening brain washed by Dion out in Quebec, may be he got his English mixed up when speaking to you. How is the Potien.

Reply to Comment

13 Feb 14:00

John

Hooray for Blossom!

Reply to Comment

13 Feb 17:31

Interested_1

It's no surprise to me either, given the fact that Harper has had a year as PM and the publicity that goes with it. Mr Dion has been leader of the opposition for 2 1/2 months, half of that time in parlimentary recess. It will be much different 6 months down the road, and I expect to see the numbers much closer.

Reply to Comment

12 Feb 15:42

7 replies so far. Join this conversation.

kwlawson

I agree Nik those numbers remain the same for Harper, but the numbers Dion will go down, if he keeps beating this Kyoto drum, Canadians do not want to buy credits from Europe period, What is in it for Dion if he is still a French citizen, dual citizenship should be abolished before you can run in Federal Politics, or work in the Public Service, or be a member of this dysfunctional Senate.

Reply to Comment

12 Feb 18:06

4 replies so far. Join this conversation.

Jan from Whitby

It is no surprise at all that PM Harper is at the top of the heap.
This man is a leader and He will lead Canada to new heights. Dion has proven in the few months as liberal leader that he is not the man to look for to lead Canada effectively.

Reply to Comment

12 Feb 18:15

5 replies so far. Join this conversation.

kwlawson

Where did you get the Numbers On Dion Nik did he run for Prime Minister or Party Leader the Leader Convention before the last one, these must be from his riding in Quebec before the last Electon, Nationally his numbers must be down near this Liz May, but your the Stats Man!

Reply to Comment

12 Feb 23:29

No replies yet. Join this conversation.

kwlawson

Best idea to come out of Quebec in years I sent councils in Metro Vancouver - Code of Conduct For Immigrants and Non Citizens! What do think about it!

Reply to Comment

13 Feb 00:37

No replies yet. Join this conversation.

kwlawson

Judges are not Independent they were appointed by Chretien and Liberals, these are Liberal Judges you can tell by their decisions these Judges think they are Parliament, keep stacking and get a good balance of Judges from the Right to offset these Liberal Judges, Beverly being the first to go.

Reply to Comment

13 Feb 13:57

1 reply so far. Join this conversation.

kwlawson

Harper deserves a A+, No problem with Judicary Committe, Judges are not Independent, you cannot find a bigger Liberal, Beverley McLachlin Chief Justice of Canada, making Laws when this is the responsibility of Parliament, To many stupid laws and decisions have come out of this Liberal Judicary, the Judicary needs more balance which Harper is doing. Dion has no defense for this, and a reminder this is still a Chretien opposition government even with Dion as leader, no wonder Canadians do not want the Liberals, 13 years of corruption is not what Canadians want again.

Reply to Comment

13 Feb 17:25

3 replies so far. Join this conversation.

Mike

These statistics are very disappointing; it shows the influence money can have on a democracy. The ads against the liberal party and specifically the leader, are taken out of context, they are intended to and do make Mr. Dion look weak. But you must remember that the debate was within the liberal party; what they had planned to do within the Kyoto protocol and what they actually accomplished. The ads are not honest; if you want honesty then you should compare the position of the conservatives on the environment during that same 13-year period. It would then be impossible for anyone to consider Stephan Harper a friend of the environment.
If the conservatives win the next election and do it with a majority, Canadians will have to suffer through a minimum of 4 years under Harpers right wing. Then in 20 or 30 years from now we will be speaking about the environment, the Canadian Wheat Board, Women rights, judicial justice the same way we now speak about the Avro Arrow Interceptor aircraft.

Reply to Comment

13 Feb 19:54

9 replies so far. Join this conversation.

Tom Good

I agree, Harper, the man, has grown in the job as he ought to but, remember, he is being compared to someone who has not been in the job----speculative, to say the least, in this Harper vs Dion contest. Tonight, I hear on the news, that the government party is going to release another series of attack ads against Dion. Could this be characterized as a "panic attack" by the government party?

As a party, the Conservatives, under Harper, have tied their foreign policy fortunes rather closely to those of George Bush and his star seems to be dimming with the Americans and the world of late. This should give Canadians pause for thought. Canada's stature in the world as an honest broker has diminished and a foreign war, supporting United States interests, has done nothing to bolster that image but it has cost Canadian lives.

Domestically, Harper has made good progress given the restraints in the minority situation. He has demonstrated fantastic flexibility on the environment/climate change issue and in the beginning of this month he managed to cut all funding to the Northern Climate Exchange in the Yukon. His Accountability Act is long overdue even if he made just a few patronage appointments a week before the Act was proclaimed. It is unfortunate the farmers did not appreciate that it was in their best interests to not have a National Wheat Marketing Board.

We have yet to be told by the government what the Canada, U.S. and Mexico integration meetings are about. This is the North American Forum or the North American UNION. Is this evolution by stealth ? Will we be citizens of the new super country called the United States of Mexicanda with the capital of Washington D.C. ???? Should fly well with most of us---Ho Ho. Do you think trust and credibility will have a role to play in the coming election as they have had in the past ?

Harper is a good corporate CEO and he knows what manoeuvres it takes to hold office. With the coming election, I am waiting for a few good tax breaks. Just politics ! ! !

Reply to Comment

14 Feb 01:45

12 replies so far. Join this conversation.

kwlawson

Report Card for Liberals is down to zero, trying to force this Kyoto scam down the throats of Canadians, But this is what Liberals are good for only, Scams,Corruption and whatelse illegal. Enivroment not a issues to some, Citizenship and Immigraton, Jobs etc etc. are. That is why I have asked the Auditor General to do a forensic audit on the following departments and Public Servants, 1. Citizenship and Immigration 2. Foreign Affairs 3. The Canadian Foreign Service, not one individual Public Servant is going to be exempted all will be investigated, their are not doing their jobs, PSAC has to much say on Polices, why shoud the onus be put on the Sponsor and Sponsored when we are paying the fee's, proof Public Servants are lazy, they have the resources to get information from other countries more so than citizens. They simply do not want to do any work. IN SHORT IF YOU NEED INFORMATION GET IT YOURSELF LAZY PUBLIC SERVANTS, UNIONS MUST BE BANDED IN FEDERAL GOVERNMENT AND IT LEADERS IN JAIL.

Reply to Comment

14 Feb 14:46

No replies yet. Join this conversation.

kwlawson

No To The Liberal Kyotto Bill this is no more than a scam to put Canadian Taxpayer's dollars in the pockets of Europeans and Dion's other country France.

Reply to Comment

14 Feb 15:43

No replies yet. Join this conversation.

kwlawson

Dion drops to -25 % , arrest of French Canadian Public Servant Official in the Finance a direct result of the Liberals billingual hiring Policies. Kyotto not to be honored by Government meets my approval, if these Wacko's of Kyotto take this case before Liberal Activist Judges, other Canadians will take these Wacko Kyotto supporters to Court after the Liberal Actvists Judges are removed, one the have been appointed by the corrupted Jean Chretien, more proof coming on this man's leadership and a dysfunctional Prime Minister. Non Kyotto's get ready for the Court's

Reply to Comment

15 Feb 14:10

No replies yet. Join this conversation.

kwlawson

Harper goes up another 25 % , Sorry but the Minister, the Deputy Minister and the Clerk of the Privy Council must held accountable and responsible for the actions of the Public Servant Official that has been arrested. Individuals in those position at the time must be held accountable and repsonsible. McCullam and Goodale are just giving hogwash to Don Neumann on Politics. Goodale must never again be a Minister, he simply will not be accountable or responsible, this is not the type of Minister we want in Canada. Wether it is CRA or Finance those Liberals must be made responsible and accountable.

Reply to Comment

15 Feb 17:44

No replies yet. Join this conversation.

Tom Good

Nik, do you think if Harper's report card poll was held today, February 15th, it would read the same ? Harper has said he will not recognize Bill C-288 passed on a vote of 161 to 113, and, if this bill is passed by the Senate and becomes law, HE will ignore it. UNBELIEVEABLE ! Harper will not recognize a law passed by parliament. Sounds as if we have a constitutional crisis brewing and Michelle Jean will have to intervene. Of course, elected "leaders" in other countries in the past have chosen to ignore the will of parliament, or whatever they call it, and they have been labelled as dictators. Another guy, called King John 792 years ago chose to ignore "parliament" and I believe the results turned out not quite as he expected. In the history of democracy, the will of the king is bound by law and I suggest King Harper needs a refresher lesson in constitutional law. I respected Harper for what he managed to accomplish in a minority parliament but he is obviously not up to the thrust and parry of a minority parliament in respect to Bill C-288----he has lost my respect and in no way do I wish to see a one man rule in my country, Canada.

Reply to Comment

15 Feb 19:40

38 replies so far. Join this conversation.

kwlawson

Dion down another 10%, Liberals must apologize for this arrested Public Servant Official and so must the Public Service Commission, this is a direct result of the billingual hiring policies and practices of the Federal government. Lucien Robillard must apologize also she created this absolutely stupid program, Down with Dion and his Liberals.

Reply to Comment

16 Feb 14:01

No replies yet. Join this conversation.

kwlawson

No apology to Goodale or Liberals needed, the Liberals caused this problem in the first with the hiring policies of Public Service Commission and the way Senior Officials are hired. Lucienne Robillard as a member of the Privy Council and Treasury Board is solely repsonesible for this mess.

Reply to Comment

16 Feb 17:04

No replies yet. Join this conversation.